Best Protein Cookies & Treats 2026
⚡ Quick Picks — Our Top 3
Protein Cookies That Actually Taste Like Cookies
The protein cookie category has exploded because they solve a real problem: you want something sweet and indulgent, but you also want to hit your protein goals. The best protein cookies deliver 15-20g of protein while actually tasting like a dessert — not a protein supplement pretending to be one.
Top Picks Compared
| Cookie | Protein | Calories | Sugar | Vegan | Best Flavor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lenny & Larry's | 16g | 420 | 28g | ✅ | Chocolate Chip |
| Quest Cookie | 15g | 250 | 1g | ❌ | Choc Chip |
| Legendary Foods Pastry | 20g | 250 | 1g | ❌ | Strawberry |
🥇 Best Overall: Lenny & Larry's Complete Cookie
These are the cookies that started the protein cookie revolution. At 16g of protein for the full cookie (8g per half), they're the closest thing to a "real" cookie in the protein snack world. Soft-baked, chewy, and available in flavors that actually taste like their names.
- Tastes like a real bakery cookie — the best flavor in the category
- 16g protein (full cookie) from plant-based sources
- Vegan and non-GMO
- Available everywhere — gas stations, grocery stores, Amazon
Heads up: At 420 calories and 28g sugar for the full cookie, this is NOT a diet food. It's a protein-enhanced dessert. If macros matter, eat half.
🥈 Best Macros: Quest Protein Cookie
Quest applies the same formula that makes their bars great — high protein, low sugar, minimal net carbs. The cookies deliver 15g protein with only 1g sugar and 250 calories.
- 15g protein, 1g sugar, 250 calories
- 9g fiber for satiety
- Low net carbs — keto-friendly
- Soft, chewy texture
🥉 Best Unique: Legendary Foods Protein Pastry
Think of these as a protein Pop-Tart. 20g of protein in a filled pastry format that's unlike any other protein snack. The Strawberry flavor with its sweet filling is the standout.
- 20g protein — highest in the cookie/pastry category
- Only 1g sugar
- Unique pastry format — filled like a Pop-Tart
- Tastes amazing toasted
FAQ
Are protein cookies healthy?
Healthi-ER than regular cookies, yes. They swap some flour and sugar for protein, fiber, and sugar alcohols. But they're still treats — not health foods. Use them to satisfy cravings while hitting protein goals.
Can protein cookies replace protein shakes?
In terms of protein delivery, some can (15-20g is comparable to a scoop of whey). But they have more calories, fat, and carbs. Use them as a dessert alternative, not a primary protein source.
Which protein cookie tastes most like a real cookie?
Lenny & Larry's, hands down. They sacrifice some macro optimization for taste. If you blind-tested it against a bakery cookie, most people couldn't tell the difference.